12 Fast Direct Mail Tests for Cheapskates

So you want to boost your direct mail response? Okay, just start shoveling money into a few dozen tests and …

What’s that? You don’t have a big budget for all the testing you’d love to do? You don’t have time to run a bunch of tests? No problem.

One of the great things about direct mail is that, with just a little ingenuity, you can test quickly and on the cheap to improve your results.

Here are 12 quick and easy testing ideas for cheapskates:

Change your outer envelope. A new color or a different size may be all it takes to get people to take a second look at a package they’ve seen too many times. You can also try switching from a teaser envelope to a plain one or vice versa. And faux express envelopes are often worth a test.

Test a new letter. It can be an all-new letter from scratch. Or a longer version of your current letter with more detail. Or a shorter version with less detail. Or a modified version with a new spin on the headlines and opening paragraphs.

Remove your brochure. Believe it or not, response often picks up without that elaborate brochure. It may be that removing the brochure simply gets people to read the letter more thoroughly. This doesn’t always work, but as tests go, you can’t get any simpler.

Include a stand-alone reply form. You should be doing this anyway, but if not, try it. It doesn’t matter if another piece already has a reply form. This is just a test. And if it works, you can make further modifications later.

Insert a lift note. This is an easy way to overcome a major objection or highlight a key benefit. Just remember to keep it short and have it signed by someone other than the person who signs the main letter. If you have a celebrity or authority who can sign it, all the better.

Strengthen your offer. This is where you can usually make the most difference. All things being equal, the best offer you can make is a free trial. The second best is a money-back guarantee. If you don’t want to change your offer completely, try turning it into a yes/no offer, or a yes/maybe offer where “yes” is a purchase and “maybe” is a request for more information. Of course, sweepstakes can always add a lift, but your customer quality will usually go downhill.

Offer something free. It’s generally better than discounting your product and gives you the opportunity to use the magic word “FREE.” It can be a free gift, free shipping, free add-ons, free subscription to your newsletter or catalog, whatever.

Add a time limit. This almost always boosts response. You can connect the time limit to your main offer or to your premium. One easy way to add this to a preexisting package or mailer is to create a simple piece of art that looks like you’ve rubber-stamped the deadline. It should be ugly and realistic.

Highlight your guarantee. In a package, you should feature it prominently in the letter, brochure, and order form. If your guarantee is strong—and it should be—you can also create an insert or lift note that explains your guarantee in detail. In a self-mailer, you should place your guarantee on the primary selling panel and on the reply panel.

Build a package around your self-mailer. You’ll need an outer envelope, basic letter, reply form, and BRE. Add your self-mailer as the brochure and presto! You have a complete direct mail package. It’s not an ideal solution but good enough for a quick test.

Mail your print ad. Just print it, fold it, and insert it into a plain envelope with a little note that says something like, “I thought you would find this interesting” or “Try this. It works.” You might also try adding a BRE or reply envelope with a live stamp to help ease response. You may even try adding a reply form so people don’t have to cut out the coupon.

Try the two-step. First mail a postcard or small self-mailer offering free information on your product. Then fulfill requests with your direct mail package. Just make sure to modify the package with envelope copy that says something like, “Here’s the information you asked for.”

Contributed by: Dean Rieck